Primary Source Analysis Worksheet Template for Students
A one-source worksheet that walks students through the questions historians ask: who made this, when, why, how reliable it is, and what it can and cannot prove. It works for letters, photographs, diaries, objects, maps and speeches, in middle school, high school or a history club. Expect about 20 to 30 minutes per source.
How to use this template
Make one copy per source. For a comparison, fill in two copies and then the comparison table at the end.
Look closely at the source before reading any caption or textbook summary. Write what you notice first.
Answer the who, when and why questions, using evidence from the source itself where you can.
Judge reliability. A source can be biased and still be useful; the question is what it is useful for.
Finish by sorting claims into "this source can prove" and "this source cannot prove."
Part 1: Identify the source
| Question | My answer | How I know (clue from the source or its record) |
|---|---|---|
| Title or short description | ||
| Type (letter, photo, object, map, speech, record, other) | ||
| Who made it? | ||
| When was it made? | ||
| Where was it made? | ||
| Who was the intended audience? |
Made at the time or later? ☐ Made at the time of the events ☐ Written or made later ☐ Scientific finding ☐ Modern reconstruction or illustration
First things I notice (before reading any caption): [three observations]
Part 2: Why was it made, and can I trust it?
Purpose: Why do you think the creator made this? [to inform, persuade, record, remember, sell, celebrate, complain]
Point of view: What did the creator believe, want or stand to gain? [answer]
Reliability checklist
☐ The creator saw the events directly, or was close in time and place
☐ The creator had no obvious reason to exaggerate or hide something
☐ The details are specific (names, dates, numbers) rather than vague
☐ Other sources from the same time agree on the main facts
☐ I know whether the source has been edited, translated or copied since it was made
Overall reliability for my question: ☐ Strong ☐ Mixed ☐ Weak. Because: [reason]
Part 3: What can it prove, and what can't it?
| Claim | Can prove | Cannot prove | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Example (the Rosetta Stone, 196 BC): "A decree for King Ptolemy V was written in three scripts." | ☐ | ☐ | The stone itself carries the same decree in hieroglyphic, Demotic and Greek, so this is supported. |
| Example: "Most Egyptians admired Ptolemy V." | ☐ | ☐ | An official decree shows what rulers and priests wanted said, not what ordinary people felt. This goes too far. |
A question this source raises that I still cannot answer: [question]
Compare with a second source (optional)
| Question | Source 1 | Source 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Who made it and when? | ||
| What do they agree on? | ||
| Where do they disagree? | ||
| What does neither one show? |
On iPhone
Examine the source and build a case from the evidence. US $2.99 upfront.
See inside PastRush · View the app on the App Store iOS 18.0 or later